A child is always a gift and never the basis of a commercial contract

At the 70th Commission on the Status of Women, the to the United Nations (14 March 2026) issued a powerful statement urging the global community to confront the growing ethical, legal, and human rights challenges posed by surrogacy. The Vatican delegation described surrogacy as a field where “technology and practice have run laps around the law and ethics,” calling for international alignment to protect women and children from what it characterizes as systemic exploitation.

The statement, presented at a side event titled “Protecting Women and Children: Combating Violence and Exploitation in Surrogacy,” emphasized that the moral and legal dimensions of the issue cannot be ignored in the pursuit of parenthood. Supported by the governments of Italy, Türkiye, and Paraguay, the session underscored what participants described as an “urgent” need to ensure dignity and justice within reproductive technology.

Central to the Holy See’s critique is the economic asymmetry that drives the global surrogacy industry. Many women, the statement notes, cite economic distress as the primary reason for becoming surrogates, while the stories that reach public attention often highlight wealthy parents commissioning surrogacy rather than affluent women offering the service.

This imbalance, the Holy See warned, reflects deeper systemic injustices: “The surrogacy industry might not survive if poverty were eradicated.” The document highlights that demand for surrogate-born children already exceeds supply, a situation that heightens risks of coercion and commercial manipulation.

Even in countries where commercial is illegal, compensation for “expenses” can often obscure hidden payments. In some cases, the Vatican delegation cautioned, women are coerced by family or social expectation, deprived of independent legal and medical advice due to their limited means, and thus vulnerable to exploitation through subtle or direct forms of pressure.

The Holy See’s submission also shifted focus to children’s rights, addressing cases where “over a dozen babies” were discovered in rented housing awaiting commissioning parents. Such scenarios, it warned, illustrate a troubling “commodification” of human life, where children risk being treated as “products” subject to market logic.

The statement draws particular attention to situations involving prenatal diagnoses of disability, where unborn children can be rejected as “flawed products.” Such attitudes, the Vatican argues, betray the inherent dignity of human life and contradict the principles enshrined in the Convention on the Rights of the Child, especially the “moral right of every child to be conceived in an act of love” and to “know and be cared for by their parents.”

In reaffirming the Church’s longstanding opposition to surrogacy, the statement references recent papal teachings, including remarks by Pope Leo XIV, who denounced surrogacy as a practice that “violates the dignity both of the child, who is reduced to a product, and of the , exploiting her body and generative power.” Pope Francis has likewise insisted that “a child is always a gift and never the basis of a commercial contract.”

These pronouncements underscore the theological foundation of the Holy See’s moral argument — that human life, parenthood, and the family derive their value from love and relational commitment, not from transactional or contractual arrangements.

More at: https://www.gaudiumpress.ca/holy-see-at-the-un-surrogacy-poses-deep-moral-and-ethical-risks-to-women-and-children/

- https://www.vaticannews.va/en/vatican-city/news/2026-03/holy-see-permanent-mission-united-nations-surrogacy-statement.html